The Charity Commission recognises four charity structures in England and Wales: the charitable incorporated organisation (CIO), the charitable company limited by guarantee, the unincorporated association and the trust. Founders often weigh a fifth, the community interest company (CIC), but a CIC isn't a charity and can't get the charity tax reliefs.
Two questions do most of the work. Do your trustees need limited liability? And do you need charity tax reliefs such as Gift Aid and business rate relief? Where you register follows from the answers. The Charity Commission's structure guidance sets the options side by side.
The two questions that decide the structure
Two questions narrow the field a long way before you look at the detail of each option.
Do your trustees need limited liability?
Which type of organisation has unlimited liability? The unincorporated one. An unincorporated association or trust has no separate legal personality, so in principle its trustees can be personally liable for its debts and legal obligations. For a small grant-funded group with no employees and no contracts in its own name, that risk is often manageable. Once you hold property, employ staff, sign service contracts or take on liabilities, limited liability is almost always the right call.
The CIO and the charitable company both give trustees limited liability, because both are incorporated. So does the CIC. The unincorporated route doesn't.
Do you need charity tax reliefs?
Charity status is worth real money. HMRC recognition, which is separate from Commission registration, unlocks Gift Aid and exemption from tax on most charitable income, and charity status also brings up to 80% off business rates on property used wholly or mainly for charitable purposes.
A CIC isn't a charity. It pays corporation tax normally and can't claim Gift Aid on its income or charitable rate relief, so if those reliefs matter to how you'll be funded, it's the wrong vehicle. Our CIC vs charity comparison has the full breakdown.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
Structure comparison table
Here's how the four compare on the points founders ask about most. Every figure is for England and Wales; Scotland (OSCR) runs a different regime, covered at the end.
| Structure | Legal personality / limited liability | Registers with | Main regulator | Charity tax reliefs (Gift Aid / rate relief) | Accounts framework | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CIO (charitable incorporated organisation) | Yes / Yes | Charity Commission only | Charity Commission | Yes, after separate HMRC recognition | Non-company: receipts & payments up to £500,000 gross income; accruals above that | Most new charities wanting incorporation without Companies House filing |
| Charitable company (limited by guarantee) | Yes / Yes | Charity Commission and Companies House | Charity Commission (primary) + Companies House | Yes, after separate HMRC recognition | Company: accruals required at all income levels | Organisations that already have a company or need Companies House presence for stakeholders |
| Unincorporated association / trust | No / No | Charity Commission (once income exceeds £5,000/year) | Charity Commission | Yes, after separate HMRC recognition | Non-company: receipts & payments up to £500,000 gross income; accruals above that | Small community groups with low liability exposure and simple finances |
| CIC (community interest company) | Yes / Yes | Companies House (CIC Regulator) | Office of the Regulator of CICs | No. No Gift Aid, no charity rate relief; corporation tax applies normally | Company: accruals required; CIC34 community interest report filed with accounts | Social enterprises that do not need charity status and want to trade or take investment |
The £500,000 receipts and payments limit applies to financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026, which includes the first year end of any charity set up now; earlier year ends used £250,000.
Sources: Charity Commission structure guidance; CC21b registration guidance; HMRC charities and tax; ORCIC.
CIO: the default for most new charities
Why do so many founders pick a CIO? It's the one structure built just for charities, and it gives you the benefits of incorporation without registering twice. A CIO registers only with the Charity Commission, not Companies House, so you've got one regulator, one set of annual filings, and no confirmation statement or Companies House accounts to keep up alongside the Commission return.
What founders need to know:
- A CIO must register with the Commission whatever its income, even before it's received any money. Other structures register once income exceeds £5,000 a year.
- Trustees have limited liability. The CIO itself can hold property, enter contracts and employ staff in its own name.
- Non-company charities (CIOs included) with gross income of £500,000 or less can prepare receipts and payments accounts instead of full accruals accounts. Above that, accruals accounts following the Charities SORP (FRS 102) are required.
- Charity tax reliefs need a separate application to HMRC after registration; registering with the Commission doesn't bring Gift Aid with it.
Is a CIO more work for trustees than an unincorporated charity? A bit, and that's the trade-off for the protection. A CIO sends the Commission its accounts and annual return every year whatever its income, and keeps a register of its trustees (and of its members, if it's an association CIO). Our page on running a CIO from year to year shows what that involves once you're up and running.
For the CIO registration itself, step by step, see the Setting Up a Charity or CIO guide.
Charitable company: when Companies House presence is preferred
A charitable company limited by guarantee gives trustees the same limited liability as a CIO, but it registers with both the Charity Commission and Companies House. That means two sets of annual filings: the Commission's annual return and accounts, and Companies House's confirmation statement and company accounts.
So why would you take that on? Usually for one of three reasons:
- The organisation already exists as a company limited by guarantee and is converting to charitable status.
- A funder, grant body or institutional partner expects or requires a Companies House registration number.
- The founders already know Companies House obligations from running other companies.
A charitable company prepares accruals accounts at every income level, unlike a CIO or unincorporated charity, which can use receipts and payments up to £500,000 of income. That adds to accountancy cost at smaller income levels.
The charity accounts service page sets out the accounts framework that applies to each structure.
Unincorporated association or trust: simplest, but no separate legal personality
An unincorporated association is the oldest and simplest form. It has no separate legal personality: in law, the organisation is its trustees or members acting together. A charitable trust works in a similar way, but it's built around a trust deed rather than a membership constitution.
What that means in practice:
- There's no corporate shield: if the organisation can't meet a debt or a legal obligation, its trustees can be personally liable for it.
- Property has to be held in the names of individual trustees (or by a nominee or custodian trustee), not in the organisation's name.
- Contracts and employment are entered into by named trustees, who are personally party to them.
- Registration with the Charity Commission is required once income exceeds £5,000 a year. Below that, an unincorporated charity can run without registering and won't appear on the public register. It can still apply to HMRC for recognition and claim Gift Aid, because HMRC only needs you registered where the law says you must be.
For a small, volunteer-run community group with no employees, no property and few contracts, an unincorporated association keeps the admin light. CIO or unincorporated? Once you employ staff, hold a lease or run sizeable events with outside suppliers, the lack of limited liability becomes a real risk, and moving to a CIO is usually the right step. An unincorporated charity can't convert in place, though: it registers a new CIO and moves its assets and activities across.
Once you're registered, the audit vs independent examination guide and the IE vs audit checker show which checks your accounts need.
CIC: when a social mission does not need charity status
Not every social mission needs a charity. A community interest company (CIC) is a company limited by shares or by guarantee that has passed a community interest test and is regulated by the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies. It's not a charity, and the Charity Commission doesn't regulate it.
Comparing a CIC with a CIO or another charitable structure, here's what changes:
- No Gift Aid. A CIC can't claim Gift Aid on donations, and its donors can't reclaim tax on what they give. That matters a lot if you're relying on public giving.
- No charity rate relief. The 80% mandatory charitable rate relief isn't available; a CIC pays business rates like any other company unless it qualifies for a different relief.
- Corporation tax applies normally to its profits, whether it reinvests them or not.
- CICs have a statutory asset lock, and CICs limited by shares also face dividend and performance caps.
- Every CIC files a CIC34 community interest company report alongside its accounts at Companies House.
A CIC is the right choice when you want to trade, take investment or pay limited returns to investors, you don't depend on Gift Aid, and you don't want a relationship with the Charity Commission. That's why social enterprises in markets where commercial discipline matters often prefer it.
For the full CIC picture, see the CIC complete guide and the CIC accounting services page. For a straight head-to-head, read CIC vs charity.
Narrow it down: structure chooser
Most founders land in one of these:
- You need Gift Aid, charity tax reliefs or rate relief: choose a charitable structure, not a CIC.
- You'll employ staff, hold a lease or sign contracts: choose a CIO, or a charitable company if a funder or partner wants a Companies House number.
- You're a small volunteer group with no staff, property or contracts: an unincorporated association keeps the paperwork light, and you can move to a CIO later.
Not sure which of those you are? Work through these three questions in order. The second and third are the ones the Commission's structure guidance uses.
- Are your purposes charitable, and do you want the charity tax reliefs? If your purposes are charitable and for the public benefit, and you want Gift Aid, rate relief and the tax exemptions, you're choosing a charity. If you want to trade with a social purpose, pay dividends or raise equity, or your purposes aren't strictly charitable, the answer to "charity or CIC?" is probably the CIC, and you can stop here.
- Does the charity need to be a corporate body? If it'll employ paid staff, deliver services under contract, sign commercial contracts or own or lease property in its own name, yes: incorporation is what lets it do those things, and it generally keeps the trustees from being personally liable for what the charity does. If it'll be small in assets, is unlikely to employ many people and mainly makes grants or runs volunteer activity, it may not need to be.
- Will it have a wider membership? That means members, beyond the trustees, who vote on the big decisions, usually at an AGM: electing the people who run it, or changing the governing document. A membership charity mustn't exist only to benefit its members, unless anyone can join or membership is a sensible way to carry out its purposes, as with an amateur sports club.
Put the last two answers together and you've got your structure:
| Wider membership | No wider membership (the trustees decide everything) | |
|---|---|---|
| Needs to be a corporate body | Association CIO, or a charitable company | Foundation CIO, or a charitable company |
| Doesn't need to be a corporate body | Unincorporated association, with a constitution | Trust, with a trust deed that names the money or other assets it starts with |
Take a lunch club for older people that meets in a village hall. Volunteers run it, it's about to take on a part-time cook, and it wants local people to join and vote on who runs it. Its purposes are charitable and it wants Gift Aid, so it's a charity. A paid employee means it should be a corporate body. Voting members mean a wider membership. That's an association CIO: one registration with the Charity Commission, using the Commission's model association constitution, and nothing to file at Companies House.
How to register once you have chosen
How you register depends on the structure you've picked. If you'd rather not do it alone, our charity registration and set-up support covers the application, HMRC recognition and the first year end.
- CIO: apply online through the Charity Commission's registration portal with your CIO constitution (your governing document) and your trustees' details. There's no Companies House step.
- Charitable company: incorporate the company at Companies House first (limited by guarantee, with charitable objects in the articles), then apply to the Charity Commission to register as a charity. You need both registrations.
- Unincorporated association or trust: once income exceeds £5,000 a year, apply to the Charity Commission through the same online portal with your governing document (the rules or the trust deed).
- CIC: apply to Companies House using the CIC application forms; there's no Charity Commission registration. The CIC Regulator (based at Companies House) assesses the community interest test.
- HMRC recognition (all charitable structures): once you've got your Charity Commission registration number, apply separately to HMRC for charitable tax recognition. A charity that doesn't have to register, such as one with income of £5,000 or less, can apply without a number. This is the step that unlocks Gift Aid and the other reliefs: Commission registration alone doesn't deliver them.
For every step of registering a CIO or a charitable company, the Setting Up a Charity or CIO guide takes you through it.
Scotland and Northern Ireland: different regimes
All of this is England and Wales law. Scotland and Northern Ireland each have their own charity law, with different structures, regulators and thresholds.
- Scotland: charities in Scotland are regulated by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR). The Scottish charitable incorporated organisation (SCIO) is Scotland's equivalent of the CIO, and the accounts and scrutiny rules differ from England and Wales.
- Northern Ireland: the regulator is the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland (CCNI), and Northern Irish charity law has its own registration requirements and thresholds.
If your charity works across borders, take advice on which jurisdiction's law governs it. Never assume England and Wales rules apply in Scotland or Northern Ireland.