CICs and Social Enterprises
CIC vs Charity: Which Structure Fits, and What Each One Costs You in Tax
For founders torn between a community interest company and a charity: what each one costs in tax, worked through for one project run both ways, plus how founders get paid, who regulates you, what you file each year and how to convert later.
Picture two community projects on the same street, doing the same work for the same people. One's set up as a charity, the other as a community interest company (CIC). By the end of the year the charity can be thousands of pounds better off, and nobody's done anything differently. The two look alike from the outside, but they sit in different legal and tax regimes. The pros and cons come down to three things: tax relief, how founders can be paid, and who regulates you.
The short answer
Choose a charity if public fundraising, Gift Aid and rates relief are central to how you'll operate. Choose a CIC if you want to pay founders a proper salary without needing Charity Commission permission, plan to earn most of your income from trading, or want a quicker way to get set up. The tax cost of the CIC route is real and it comes round every year: without Gift Aid every £1 you raise stays at £1, and without charitable rate relief you pay full business rates on any property you occupy.
What a CIC is, and what a charity is
A community interest company is a type of limited company designed for social enterprise. It files at Companies House and submits a community interest statement confirming its activities benefit the community. It's regulated by the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies, which sits within Companies House. For a deeper account of how CICs work, see the CIC complete guide.
A charity is an organisation set up for charitable purposes for the public benefit, regulated by the Charity Commission for England and Wales. It must register with the Commission once its income is over £5,000 a year (a CIO must register whatever its income). Charitable status is what unlocks the tax reliefs that make public fundraising pay.
The regulator split
That's the basic difference between a CIC and a charity, and it shapes everything each one has to file. A CIC answers to the Office of the Regulator of CICs at Companies House. It sits on the Companies House register with a company number, and the rules it lives by are the Companies Act 2006, the 2004 Act that created CICs and the CIC Regulations, not the Charities Act. A charity answers to the Charity Commission for England and Wales, appears on the Commission's public register and lives by the Charities Act 2011 (as amended by the Charities Act 2022).
A charity has a second relationship, too. HMRC has to recognise it before it can claim Gift Aid or any other charity tax relief, and that's separate from registering with the Commission. A CIC has nothing equivalent, because there are no charity reliefs for it to claim.
Scotland is a separate regime. Scottish charities are regulated by OSCR, not the Charity Commission. If you're based in Scotland, the thresholds and rules differ from the ones here.
Tax: the decisive difference
This is where the two part company, and where getting the comparison wrong costs you most.
A charity recognised by HMRC pays no tax on most types of income used for charitable purposes. It can claim Gift Aid at 25p for every £1 of eligible donations from UK taxpayers, as long as the donor has paid at least as much income tax or capital gains tax in the year as all charities will reclaim on their donations. It also qualifies for charitable rate relief of up to 80% off business rates on property used wholly or mainly for charitable purposes, and the local council can top that up to 100% if it chooses.
A CIC gets none of these reliefs. It pays corporation tax like any other company, at rates from the 19% small profits rate up to the 25% main rate. It can't claim Gift Aid on donations, and it doesn't qualify for charitable rate relief. That's a hard rule, not an edge case: CICs are not charities, so the reliefs don't apply to them.
Here's what that means for one project run both ways. Say it raises £40,000 in donations from UK taxpayers who all sign Gift Aid declarations, occupies premises with a £12,000 business rates bill, and makes £20,000 profit from course fees, where running the courses is the charity's purpose. The figures are illustrative; the rules are the ones above.
| In the year | Run as a CIC | Run as a charity |
|---|---|---|
| £40,000 of donations | £40,000 (no Gift Aid) | £50,000, after £10,000 of Gift Aid |
| £12,000 business rates bill | Pays £12,000 (no charitable rate relief) | Pays £2,400 after 80% relief, or less if the council tops it up |
| £20,000 profit from course fees | Corporation tax of £3,800 at 19% | No tax, because the trading is the charity's own charitable work |
| Difference over the year | £23,400 worse off | £23,400 better off |
Scale it up and the gap grows. A charity raising £100,000 in eligible donations can claim another £25,000 through Gift Aid. A CIC raising the same amount keeps exactly £100,000, and then pays corporation tax on any profits from its activities. If the charity's trading isn't its charitable work, say a café open to anyone, the small trading exemption or a trading subsidiary decides the tax instead.
CIC vs Charity Tax Calculator
A charity can claim Gift Aid, gets up to 80% off business rates and pays no tax on trading that is part of its purpose. A CIC gets none of those and pays corporation tax like any company. Enter your yearly figures to see what that difference is worth for your project.
Gifts from individuals who pay at least as much UK income tax or capital gains tax as would be claimed. A charity claims 25p for every £1; a CIC can't claim Gift Aid at all.
For premises in England used mainly for your charitable work. A charity gets 80% off and the council can choose to cancel the rest; a CIC gets no charitable rate relief. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland run their own schemes.
For example course fees, where running the courses is what the organisation is for. A charity pays no tax on this profit; a CIC pays corporation tax on it. If the trading isn't part of the purpose, use the small trading exemption checker instead.
Assumes premises in England, a 12-month year, a company with no associated companies, and a charity recognised by HMRC whose donors have paid enough tax for Gift Aid. Corporation tax uses the 2026/27 rates: 19% on profits up to £50,000, 25% over £250,000 and marginal relief in between. Only the profit you enter is taxed in the CIC column; whether a particular grant or donation counts towards a CIC's taxable profit depends on its terms. If the council cancels the charity's remaining 20% of rates, the gap is bigger. Other reliefs a CIC might get on its rates are not counted.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
The asset lock: what it locks in each structure
Both structures restrict what happens to their assets, but in different ways.
A CIC has a statutory asset lock under the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004. Its assets have to be used for the community, or passed to another asset-locked body (a charity, another CIC or certain other organisations), and that includes when the CIC winds up. CICs limited by shares also have a dividend cap: where their articles let them pay private investors, total dividends can't be more than 35% of the CIC's profits. The CIC guidance pack's chapters on the asset lock and on shares and the dividend cap set out the detail.
A charity's assets are locked to its charitable purposes too, and the Charity Commission enforces that. Anything left when a charity closes has to go to another charity or charitable purpose; it can't be shared out among members or founders. There's no dividend cap because a charity can't pay dividends at all.
Want to build value you can sell later? Neither structure lets you, not the way an ordinary private company does. A CIC allows some dividends within the cap. A charity doesn't allow profits to be paid out at all.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
Paying founders and directors
For founders who need to earn a living from what they're building, this is often what settles it.
A CIC director can be paid a salary, like any company director. There's no Charity Commission check on it, but the pay has to be reasonable and the arrangements transparent, and the CIC34 report shows what directors were paid each year. CICs limited by shares can also pay dividends to shareholders, within the cap.
A charity trustee can be paid only if the charity's governing document authorises it, or the Charity Commission gives specific permission. Many smaller charities pay no trustees at all. A charity can employ staff, a founder in an executive role included, but being a trustee is usually unpaid, and the Commission will look closely at any payment. See the CIC services page for how director pay plays out in practice, and the CIC complete guide for the regulatory detail.
Registration and filing burden compared
The structure you choose decides who you file with each year, and by when.
| Structure | Registers with | Files each year | Deadline | Extra CIC filing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CIO (charitable incorporated organisation) | Charity Commission only | Annual return to the Charity Commission with its accounts and trustees' annual report, whatever its income | 10 months after the year end | N/A |
| Charitable company | Charity Commission and Companies House | Annual return to the Commission, plus a confirmation statement and accounts to Companies House | 10 months for the Commission; nine months for the accounts at Companies House | N/A |
| CIC (limited by guarantee) | Companies House only | Confirmation statement and accounts to Companies House | Nine months for the accounts | CIC34 community interest company report filed with the accounts, £15 |
| CIC (limited by shares) | Companies House only | Confirmation statement and accounts to Companies House | Nine months for the accounts | CIC34 community interest company report filed with the accounts, £15, with dividend details if it's declared any |
The big plus of the CIO form is that it registers only with the Charity Commission. A charitable company registers with both the Commission and Companies House, so it has two sets of filings and two deadlines. A CIC registers only at Companies House, but it files the CIC34 community interest company report with its accounts every year, and Companies House charges £15 to file it.
Converting between the two
You can convert either way, but it's never just a form.
A CIC converting to a charity passes a special resolution, and the change needs a statement from the Charity Commission that the company will be a charity and a decision from the CIC Regulator (Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004, section 54). Its purposes have to be exclusively charitable, so the articles usually need rewriting, and you ask the Commission for its statement through a charity registration application. A CIC can also convert to a CIO. The asset lock the CIC already has helps, but the governing document changes and Companies House filings still make it a real project.
A charity converting to a CIC has to be a charitable company: an unincorporated charity or trust can't convert, because a CIC must be a limited company. It needs the Charity Commission's written consent first. And the property it already holds doesn't become the CIC's to use freely; it stays held on trust for the charitable purposes the company had before it converted. A charity can't simply hand its assets to a CIC either, though it can pay a CIC to do work that furthers the charity's own purposes. The gov.uk guide to choosing a charity structure is the starting point, and take legal advice before you start either process.
Decision walk-through: which one fits your situation
Run through these in order. The first one that applies usually gives you the answer.
- Is public fundraising with Gift Aid a meaningful part of how you'll be funded? If yes, a charity is almost certainly the right structure. The 25% uplift on donations is hard to match any other way, and a CIC can't get it at all. Some grant funders only fund registered charities, too.
- Do you need to pay founders a salary from day one, without asking the Charity Commission? If yes, a CIC gives you more room. A charity can employ a founder as staff, but paying a trustee needs specific authorisation.
- Will most of your income come from trading, contracts or fees rather than donations? A CIC may fit more naturally, especially if your customers are councils or commissioners who expect to contract with a company. A charity can trade too, but trading that isn't its charitable work brings its own tax rules.
- Do you want one regulator and a simple start? A CIO registers only with the Charity Commission. A CIC registers only at Companies House. A charitable company has to register with both. So if it's CIO vs CIC, both avoid registering twice; they differ in almost every other way.
- Will you occupy premises and want rates relief? Charitable rate relief of up to 80% isn't open to a CIC. For a project with a building, that can be a lot of money.
If you're leaning towards a CIC, how to set up a CIC takes you through the forms, the fee and the first year, and the CIC accounting services page shows what ongoing support looks like. On the charity side, the guide to setting up a charity or CIO takes you through the Charity Commission process.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a CIC a charity?
- No. A community interest company is a type of limited company, regulated by the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies. The Charity Commission doesn't regulate it, it has a company number rather than a charity number, and it gets no charity tax reliefs. The law's explicit: even a CIC set up for charitable purposes is treated as not being a charity.
- Can a CIC claim Gift Aid?
- No. Gift Aid is only for charities and community amateur sports clubs (CASCs) recognised by HMRC. A CIC can take donations, but it can't claim Gift Aid on them.
- Does a CIC pay corporation tax?
- Yes, the same way as any limited company: 19% on profits up to £50,000, 25% on profits over £250,000, and marginal relief in between. Charities don't pay tax on most kinds of income, as long as it's used for charitable purposes.
- Can a CIC get business rates relief?
- Not charitable rate relief. That's up to 80% off, and the council can top it up to 100%, but it's only for charities and community amateur sports clubs. A CIC doesn't qualify.
- What is the CIC asset lock?
- It's a rule in law that stops a CIC's assets going to its members. Assets can only leave the CIC at full market value, to an asset-locked body (such as another CIC or a charity) named in its articles or approved by the CIC Regulator, or for the benefit of the community.
- Can CIC directors be paid?
- Yes. A CIC director can be paid a salary, as long as the pay is reasonable and the arrangements are transparent, and the CIC34 report shows it each year. CICs limited by shares also have a dividend cap on what goes to shareholders. Charity trustees, by contrast, can be paid only where the governing document or the Charity Commission expressly allows it.
- Can a CIC convert to a charity, or a charity to a CIC?
- Yes, both ways, with conditions. A CIC becomes a charity by special resolution, with a statement from the Charity Commission and a decision from the CIC Regulator, and it can also convert to a CIO. A charity can become a CIC only if it's a charitable company, with the Commission's written consent, and the property it already holds stays tied to its charitable purposes. Take advice before starting either.
- Which is easier to set up, a CIC or a charity?
- A CIC, usually. It's one application to Companies House (£115 online) with a community interest statement, and the CIC Regulator's approval happens inside it. To register a charity, the Charity Commission has to be satisfied about your charitable purposes and public benefit, which takes longer.
- Can a charity own a CIC?
- Yes. A charity can hold the shares in a CIC that trades for it. The CIC can pass its profits up to the charity as a donation, and a subsidiary pays no corporation tax on profits it gives to its parent charity. The asset lock allows the payment as long as the charity's named in the CIC's articles or the CIC Regulator agrees.
- Do CICs have trustees?
- No. CICs have directors, not trustees. Trustees belong to charities: they're the people legally responsible for running the charity.
Need help with your charity's accounts?
Tell us about your charity, CIC or social enterprise and we will arrange a short introductory call.