Trustee Compliance
HMRC Recognition vs Charity Commission Registration: The Two Separate Steps
Registering with the Charity Commission and getting recognised by HMRC are two applications to two different bodies. Registration puts you on the public register. Recognition is what gets you Gift Aid and the other tax reliefs.
The charity number arrives, someone tries to claim Gift Aid, and nothing happens. That's how a lot of founders and trustees find out. Charity Commission registration and HMRC recognition are two entirely separate applications to two separate bodies. Registration puts your charity on the public register. Recognition is what gets you the tax reliefs.
The short answer
Registering with the Charity Commission makes you a registered charity: you're on the public register, you get a charity number and the Commission regulates you. HMRC recognition is a separate application to HMRC, and it's what makes you eligible for charity tax reliefs, including Gift Aid and the Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme (GASDS). You can be registered with the Commission without being recognised by HMRC yet. Until HMRC recognises your charity, you can't claim Gift Aid or most other charity tax reliefs. So is HMRC the same as the Charity Commission? No: one regulates your charity, the other runs its tax reliefs.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
What Charity Commission registration gives you
In England and Wales, once your income goes over £5,000 per year, you must register with the Charity Commission. A charitable incorporated organisation (CIO) must register whatever its income, and files a full annual return every year from then on. You get three things from it.
- A charity number and an entry on the public register. Your charity appears on the public register, which donors, funders and grant-makers can search. Many grant applications ask for a charity number.
- Public accountability. Anyone can look up your charity's name, purposes, trustees, income and spending, and funders often do before they give.
- A regulator. The Commission becomes your regulator. It sets the rules you comply with, deals with serious incident reports and has powers to step in where a charity's being mismanaged.
What registration doesn't give you: Gift Aid, GASDS, exemption from income or corporation tax on charitable income, or any of HMRC's other charity reliefs. Those need a separate step.
What HMRC recognition gives you
Recognition is what opens up the charity tax reliefs. Once you're recognised, your charity gets these.
- Gift Aid. Your charity can claim 25p for every £1 donated by a UK taxpayer who's signed a valid Gift Aid declaration. For smaller charities it's often the most valuable relief of all.
- Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme (GASDS). A top-up on small cash and contactless donations of £30 or less, on up to £8,000 of donations per tax year, without individual declarations. The 10x matching rule applies: the GASDS donations you claim on can't be more than ten times the donations you claim Gift Aid on in the same year.
- Tax exemptions on charitable income. Charities don't pay tax on most types of income as long as the money's used for charitable purposes. You only need a tax return if non-exempt income comes in or HMRC sends you a notice.
- Other reliefs. These include Stamp Duty Land Tax relief, inheritance tax relief on gifts to charity, and the higher-rate Gift Aid reclaim that donors paying income tax above the basic rate can make for themselves. Your recognition letter also lets your bank pay interest without taking tax off (gov.uk on reclaiming tax).
Why one does not follow automatically from the other
Here's the bit most founders miss. The Charity Commission and HMRC are entirely separate bodies, with separate registers, separate applications and separate criteria. Nothing passes automatically from one to the other. Finishing your Commission registration doesn't start an HMRC application, and HMRC won't treat your entry on the Commission's register as recognition.
They're checking different things. The Commission asks whether your organisation is set up for exclusively charitable purposes under the law of England and Wales, and whether it's run by fit and proper people. HMRC asks whether it meets HMRC's definition of a charity for tax, and whether the people managing it are fit and proper to do so. The tests overlap a lot, but the applications are separate.
In practice most charities send the HMRC application straight after the Commission registration comes through, because HMRC wants the charity number. It goes to HMRC through its own online service; the Commission doesn't pass anything on.
Comparison: Commission registration versus HMRC recognition
| Charity Commission registration | HMRC recognition | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Entry on the public charity register; assigns a charity number | HMRC status confirming eligibility for charity tax reliefs |
| What it gets you | Charity number (needed for many grants); public register entry; Commission regulatory framework | Gift Aid; GASDS; exemption from tax on most charitable income; other HMRC charity reliefs |
| Who you apply to | Charity Commission for England and Wales | HM Revenue and Customs (via the online charities and tax service) |
| When required | Income over £5,000/year; CIOs always; not required for excepted or exempt charities | Required to access any HMRC charity tax relief; no income threshold |
| Regulator | Charity Commission (ongoing regulator) | HMRC (administers tax reliefs; the Commission remains your regulator) |
How to apply for HMRC recognition
This is the step people often call HMRC charity registration, and it's how you register a charity for Gift Aid. You apply through HMRC's online service, starting at gov.uk/charities-and-tax. It's a form-filling job rather than a judgement call, and you'll usually want these ready before you start.
- Your legal structure and governing document. You'll need to supply your governing document: a constitution, trust deed, memorandum and articles, or CIO constitution. HMRC uses it, and your charitable objectives, to check your purposes are exclusively charitable.
- Your Commission registration details (if you're registered). Your registration number goes into the application. If your charity has to register with the Commission, do that first: one of HMRC's conditions is that the charity has complied with any requirement to be registered. A charity that doesn't have to register can apply straight away.
- Your bank account details and accounts. HMRC asks for the charity's bank account, which is where Gift Aid repayments are paid, and its financial accounts.
- The people running your finances. You choose up to two authorised officials, who manage the charity's tax (claiming Gift Aid, for example) and are the only people in the charity who can contact HMRC about it, and two to four responsible persons, who are legally accountable for running the charity, such as a trustee or the treasurer. HMRC asks for their dates of birth and National Insurance numbers (gov.uk on who can run your charity's finances). Everyone who deals with your finances must pass HMRC's fit and proper persons test, which you can show by asking each of them to sign a declaration. You only send it if HMRC asks, but keep it while they're with you and for 4 years after they leave. If someone outside the charity will make your claims, that's a nominee, and you still need an authorised official inside it.
- Submit the application online. Use HMRC's online service via gov.uk/charities-and-tax. You'll need to sign in, and you can set up sign-in details if you don't have them. HMRC changes the service from time to time, so start from that page rather than an old form reference.
- Wait for HMRC's confirmation before claiming. Don't send a Gift Aid claim until HMRC has confirmed your recognition in writing. Claims sent before recognition will be rejected. HMRC's letter gives you your charity tax reference, which you use on all your claims and letters to HMRC, and explains how to claim (HMRC's detailed guidance, chapter 2).
How long does recognition take? HMRC's guidance doesn't give a set time, so we'd apply as soon as your Commission registration comes through, not when the first big donation arrives. And if your officials, bank account or name change later, tell HMRC on form ChV1 at least a month before you claim using the new details.
Special cases: excepted charities, exempt charities and CASCs
Not every charity is on the Charity Commission's register. The law keeps two kinds off it.
- Excepted charities (certain kinds, including many churches and Scout and Guide groups) don't have to register with the Commission unless their income is over £100,000, though they're still charities in law. They can still apply for HMRC recognition and claim Gift Aid. Excepted charities below that line don't appear on the public register.
- Exempt charities (certain universities, museums and other bodies with a principal regulator) are off the Commission's register too, but they're charities in law, and they apply to HMRC for recognition the same way.
- Community Amateur Sports Clubs (CASCs) are recognised by HMRC and can claim Gift Aid, but they aren't registered charities and the Charity Commission doesn't regulate them. CASCs have their own registration with HMRC and get different reliefs, so don't treat a CASC as a charity.
If you're in one of these groups, your rules are specific, and not everything above will apply to you. Check the Commission's or HMRC's guidance for your category, or take advice.
What "recognised by HMRC" does not mean
Being recognised doesn't make HMRC a second regulator of your charity, though people sometimes read it that way. HMRC runs the tax reliefs and checks you keep meeting the conditions for them. The Charity Commission stays your regulator for everything else: complying with charity law, governance, how charitable funds are used, and public accountability. If the Commission has concerns about your charity, recognition won't protect you from regulatory action.
Nor does it make you exempt from all tax for good. Income that doesn't qualify for relief is still taxable: profits from non-primary-purpose trading that goes over the small trading exemption limits, for example. Recognition is the way into the reliefs, not a way round the detailed rules on each one.
Next steps
Registered but not yet recognised? Your next step is the online application at gov.uk/charities-and-tax. Once you're recognised, our guide to declarations, claims and the Gift Aid rules takes you through claiming. For the wider set-up, from choosing a structure to the Commission application itself, see our step-by-step guide to setting up a charity or CIO. And if you'll be collecting cash, the GASDS rules post covers the small donations scheme in detail, including the 10x matching rule and the community buildings rules.
If you'd prefer to hand the HMRC recognition application and ongoing Gift Aid claiming to a charity and social enterprise specialist, the Gift Aid service covers the full process from recognition through to regular claim submissions.
Frequently asked questions
- Do I need to register with HMRC as well as the Charity Commission?
- Yes. They're two separate steps with two separate bodies. Commission registration gives you a charity number and an entry on the public register. HMRC recognition, which you apply for separately through HMRC's online service (start at gov.uk/charities-and-tax), is what gets your charity Gift Aid and the other tax reliefs.
- Can a charity claim Gift Aid without HMRC recognition?
- No. As gov.uk puts it, to benefit from charity tax reliefs 'you must be recognised by HM Revenue and Customs'. Commission registration on its own doesn't get you Gift Aid. Our Gift Aid complete guide explains how recognition, declarations and claims fit together.
- What is the difference between a registered charity and one recognised by HMRC?
- A registered charity is on the Charity Commission's public register, regulated by the Commission, with a charity number. A charity recognised by HMRC has made a separate application to HMRC and can use Gift Aid, GASDS and the tax exemptions on charitable income. HMRC gives it a charity tax reference, which is a different number from the charity number. You can be registered with the Commission but not yet recognised by HMRC. The reverse only works for a charity that doesn't have to register, such as one with income of £5,000 or less.
- Do small charities under £5,000 need HMRC recognition?
- They need it to claim Gift Aid, and they can get it. A charity with income of £5,000 or less doesn't have to register with the Commission (CIOs are the exception: they always register). HMRC's condition is only that a charity has complied with any requirement to register (Finance Act 2010, Schedule 6, paragraph 3), so an unregistered charity under £5,000 can apply for recognition and claim Gift Aid once it's recognised. A village hall committee raising £3,000 a year, say, can be recognised and claim on its Gift Aid donations without ever joining the register.
- What do I need to apply for HMRC recognition?
- HMRC's online service asks for your charity's bank account details and financial accounts, details of its officials (including dates of birth and National Insurance numbers), its registration number if it's registered with a regulator, its charitable objectives and its governing document. HMRC changes the service from time to time, so start from gov.uk/charities-and-tax rather than an old form number.
- Is HMRC recognition the same as being on the charity register?
- No. The Charity Commission holds the charity register, which lists registered charities with their numbers, purposes and accounts. HMRC recognition is a separate status, held by HMRC, that gets you the tax reliefs. The two don't depend on each other, though most mid-sized and larger charities have both.
- Can a charitable company get recognition without Commission registration?
- Only if it doesn't have to register with the Commission, for example because its income is £5,000 or less. A charitable company over that level must register with both the Commission and Companies House, and HMRC recognition depends on it having done so. HMRC also needs to see that the company is set up for charitable purposes only. In practice most charitable companies finish the Commission registration first and apply to HMRC straight after.
Need help with your charity's accounts?
Tell us about your charity, CIC or social enterprise and we will arrange a short introductory call.