Independent Examination and Audit
Who can carry out an independent examination of charity accounts?
It depends on your charity's gross income for the year being examined. At or below £250,000 (£500,000 for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026), any independent person with the right ability and practical experience can do it. Above that, the examiner has to be a member of one of the bodies listed in the Charities Act 2011, or a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners. Either way, they can't be a trustee, a member of staff, your bookkeeper or anyone close to the trustees.
Can an experienced treasurer from another charity examine your accounts? Quite possibly, if yours is small enough. The Charities Act 2011 has two tiers for independent examiners, and one figure decides which applies to you: your gross income in the financial year being examined. If the person you pick doesn't qualify at that income, the examination doesn't meet the Act, and that comes back to bite when you file the accounts with your annual return.
The basic rule: independent and capable
For a charity with gross income of £250,000 or less (£500,000 or less for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026), the Act asks for an independent person who has the requisite ability and practical experience to carry out a competent examination. It's your trustees who appoint them, and the law puts the judgement on them: they have to reasonably believe the person can do the job (section 145).
What counts as capable depends on your accounts and on what the examiner actually has to check. The Commission's guidance for examiners, CC32, says someone with financial awareness and a head for numbers can usually examine simple receipts and payments accounts. Accruals accounts are a different job: the examiner needs a good grasp of accounting principles, accounting standards and the Charities SORP, and CC32 recommends trustees choose someone from one of the listed bodies for them, even below the income line.
So at this level a retired accountant, an experienced treasurer from another charity, or a qualified bookkeeper who knows the charity sector can all do it, as long as they're genuinely independent of your charity and its trustees.
The listed-body rule for larger charities
Once gross income goes over £250,000 (£500,000 for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026), the rules tighten. Exactly on the line still counts as the basic rule. Above it, the examiner has to be a member of one of the bodies listed in section 145(4) of the Charities Act 2011, or a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners. The Act sets that list, not the Charity Commission, and an experienced examiner outside it can't act, however capable they are.
The bodies listed in section 145(4) are:
- The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW)
- The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS)
- The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland (ICAI)
- The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA)
- The Association of Authorised Public Accountants (AAPA)
- The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA)
- The Association of Accounting Technicians (AAT)
- The Association of International Accountants (AIA)
- The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA)
- The Chartered Governance Institute UK and Ireland (named in the Act by its former title, the Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators)
- The Institute of Financial Accountants (IFA)
- The Certified Public Accountants Association (CPAA)
Those twelve bodies, plus Fellows of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners (ordinary ACIE membership isn't enough), are the only routes in. The Commission repeats the list in its guidance for trustees, CC31. It's current membership that counts, not a qualification someone once earned, so an examiner who's let their membership lapse doesn't meet the test. CC32 also tells examiners to check their own body's rules allow them to take the role, and whether they need a practising certificate to do it.
Independent Examination vs Audit Checker
The Charities Act sets clear gates. For financial years ending before 30 September 2026: independent examination once gross income passes £25,000, a qualified examiner and accruals accounts above £250,000, and a statutory audit above £1m income (or £250,000 income with assets over £3.26m). For financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026 the gates rise to £40,000, £500,000, and £1.5m income (or £500,000 income with assets over £5m). Enter your figures, year end and structure to see where your charity sits, which accounts and SORP apply, what goes to the Charity Commission and the date it's due.
Total gross income for the financial year, before any expenditure.
The aggregate value of assets before deducting liabilities. Only relevant once income exceeds the accruals threshold (£250,000, or £500,000 for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026).
The month your accounts run to. It's the year end that decides which thresholds you're on: years ending on or after 30 September 2026 use the higher figures (examination above £40,000, qualified examiner and accruals above £500,000, audit above £1.5m income or £500,000 income with assets over £5m), and earlier year ends keep the old ones.
Most charities' years end on the last day of a month. If yours doesn't (5 April, say), pick the day here.
Charitable companies must always prepare accruals accounts, whatever their income. A CIC isn't a charity, so this checker doesn't cover it.
The full check runs on the England and Wales rules. Scotland has its own regime and all Scottish charities need some external scrutiny, so for Scotland you'll get the filing date and what goes to OSCR only. Northern Ireland isn't covered.
Gross income exceeds £25,000, so independent examination is required. Below £250,000 any suitably experienced independent person can examine. We've assumed a 12-month year. A first year or a changed year end can be longer or shorter, which can move the SORP answer, so check your dates.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
Which year's income decides it
It's the gross income in the accounts being examined, not last year's figure or an average. If your income crosses the line for the first time this year, this year's accounts need an examiner who meets the listed-body rule, even if someone else was fine last year. Where the line sits depends on your year end. For years ending before 30 September 2026, any independent person with the skills can examine once income is over £25,000, and above £250,000 the examiner must be in a listed body (or an ACIE Fellow). For years ending on or after 30 September 2026, those figures are £40,000 and £500,000. Our guide to audit and examination thresholds by year end sets every line side by side.
Here's how that plays out. Take a charity with £300,000 of income and a 31 March 2026 year end: it needs a listed-body examiner, because the £250,000 figure applies. The same charity with the same income for its year ending 31 March 2027 doesn't, because the line has moved to £500,000.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
When a full audit is required instead
Past the audit lines (income over £1 million, or over £250,000 with gross assets over £3.26 million; for years ending on or after 30 September 2026, over £1.5 million, or over £500,000 with gross assets over £5 million), or where your governing document requires a statutory audit, an independent examination isn't an option at all. Then the accounts need an audit, by someone eligible to be a statutory auditor under the Companies Act rules or a member of a body named in regulations; how we run a charity audit explains that step. The section 145(4) list above is for examiners only, so it doesn't tell you who can audit. If you're getting close to any of these lines, plan ahead, because an audit needs more lead time than an examination.
The examiner's independence requirement
At both income levels, independence isn't up for negotiation. The test is whether the examiner is, or could be seen to be, influenced by a close personal relationship with your trustees or by being involved in running the charity day to day. That's not the same as having no link with the charity at all: CC32 says a member or supporter can examine your accounts. But the examiner can't be:
- A trustee or officer of the charity
- An employee of the charity
- A business partner or close relative of any of the above, such as a spouse or civil partner, parent, child, brother or sister
- Anyone with a financial interest in the charity's affairs
CC32 adds that an examiner shouldn't be a material donor. It also asks them to think twice if they depend on the charity as a beneficiary, have sat on a committee overseeing its finances or fundraising in the year they're examining, or have accepted gifts or hospitality from the charity or its trustees.
Charities sometimes assume their bookkeeper can do the examination because they aren't a trustee. They can't. Nobody can independently review their own work, so whoever keeps the records being examined isn't independent of them. The Commission does let the examiner help prepare the accounts, as long as they're not involved in keeping the accounting records or in the charity's day-to-day management, and the trustees still review and approve the accounts.
CICs and other non-charitable organisations
None of this applies to a community interest company (CIC). CICs are overseen by the CIC Regulator and file at Companies House, not with the Charity Commission, so they come under the Companies Act audit rules instead. A small CIC can use the small company audit exemption, which is a different mechanism altogether, and the listed-body rule only ever applies to charities.
Appointing an examiner: practical steps for trustees
Making sure the accounts get the right outside check each year is the trustees' job, and the appointment is a personal one: a named person is appointed, does the examination and signs the report. Before you appoint anyone, confirm:
- Your charity's gross income for the year being examined
- Whether that's above or below the listed-body line for your year end (see the table above)
- If it's above, that the person you have in mind is a current member of a body listed in section 145(4), or a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners
- That they've no connection with the charity that would undermine their independence
- That your governing document doesn't require anything more than an independent examination
It's good practice to get a short written confirmation from the examiner of their eligibility and independence. It's handy to have on file if the Charity Commission ever asks.
We carry out independent examinations at every income level, including for charities registered in Scotland and Northern Ireland. Here's how an examination with us runs, from first call to finished report. Or if you'd rather talk it through first, get in touch.
Need help with your charity's accounts?
Tell us about your charity, CIC or social enterprise and we will arrange a short introductory call.