Independent Examination and Audit
What is an independent examination of charity accounts?
An independent examination is an outside check of a charity's accounts by someone with no ties to its trustees. The examiner reviews your records, compares the accounts with them and with last year, asks about anything odd, then reports whether anything worried them. It's lighter than an audit, and in England and Wales it's needed once income is over £25,000 (£40,000 for years ending on or after 30 September 2026).
Someone from outside your charity goes through your books, checks the accounts against them, asks the trustees about anything that looks odd, and then writes a short report saying whether anything worried them. That's an independent examination. It's the lighter of the two kinds of outside check the Charities Act 2011 allows, and the other one is a full audit.
It isn't a rubber stamp, though. The examiner works to directions the Charity Commission sets, and some problems they have to report to the Commission themselves. Most registered charities in the middle income band go this way rather than having an audit.
Does your charity need one?
In England and Wales you need one once your gross income is over £25,000, unless you need an audit instead. At or below the line the Act doesn't ask for any outside check, though your governing document might. At the top end, an examination stops being allowed once an audit is compulsory: income over £1 million, or over £250,000 with gross assets over £3.26 million. All three figures moved up for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026, so from a 31 March 2027 year end the examination line is £40,000 and the audit lines are £1.5 million, or £500,000 with gross assets over £5 million.
A funder or your governing document can insist on an audit at any size. Our guide to audit and examination thresholds by year end lays every line out side by side, and the examination or audit checker tells you which one your figures need.
Scotland's different. Every charity on the Scottish register needs an examination or an audit, whatever its income, so there's no lower line at all.
Independent Examination vs Audit Checker
The Charities Act sets clear gates. For financial years ending before 30 September 2026: independent examination once gross income passes £25,000, a qualified examiner and accruals accounts above £250,000, and a statutory audit above £1m income (or £250,000 income with assets over £3.26m). For financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026 the gates rise to £40,000, £500,000, and £1.5m income (or £500,000 income with assets over £5m). Enter your figures, year end and structure to see where your charity sits, which accounts and SORP apply, what goes to the Charity Commission and the date it's due.
Total gross income for the financial year, before any expenditure.
The aggregate value of assets before deducting liabilities. Only relevant once income exceeds the accruals threshold (£250,000, or £500,000 for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026).
The month your accounts run to. It's the year end that decides which thresholds you're on: years ending on or after 30 September 2026 use the higher figures (examination above £40,000, qualified examiner and accruals above £500,000, audit above £1.5m income or £500,000 income with assets over £5m), and earlier year ends keep the old ones.
Most charities' years end on the last day of a month. If yours doesn't (5 April, say), pick the day here.
Charitable companies must always prepare accruals accounts, whatever their income. A CIC isn't a charity, so this checker doesn't cover it.
The full check runs on the England and Wales rules. Scotland has its own regime and all Scottish charities need some external scrutiny, so for Scotland you'll get the filing date and what goes to OSCR only. Northern Ireland isn't covered.
Gross income exceeds £25,000, so independent examination is required. Below £250,000 any suitably experienced independent person can examine. We've assumed a 12-month year. A first year or a changed year end can be longer or shorter, which can move the SORP answer, so check your dates.
Your result
Your answer's ready. Press below to see it.
What the examiner actually does
There's a set method. The Commission's guidance for examiners, CC32, gives 13 directions, and they carry legal weight because the Commission makes them under section 145(5)(b) of the Act. Put plainly, the work runs like this:
- They check they're allowed to do it. Is your charity eligible for an examination rather than an audit? Are they independent of your charity, and do they have the right skills (and, at higher incomes, the right membership) for your size?
- They plan the work around what your charity does and where its money comes from, and agree a timetable with you.
- They look at your records. Were proper accounting records kept, and do the accounts agree with them?
- They test the judgement calls. With accruals accounts that means your accounting policies and estimates, how restricted and unrestricted money has been treated, whether related party transactions are disclosed, and whether the trustees have thought about the charity carrying on (going concern). Receipts and payments accounts get a lighter version of this.
- They check the form of the accounts. Receipts and payments or accruals, laid out the way the regulations require.
- They compare this year with last year. Yes, the prior year's figures come into it. The examiner runs what CC32 calls an analytical review, looking for big changes between the two years and chasing anything that hasn't been explained.
- They read your trustees' annual report alongside the accounts, to make sure the two tell the same story.
- They write and sign the report, once your trustees have approved the accounts.
They also keep working papers showing what they did, so a third party could see the directions were followed.
What an examiner doesn't do is go looking for fraud, test your internal controls or say the accounts give a "true and fair view". That's audit work. The examiner's job is narrower: to say whether anything has come to their attention that suggests a problem with the specific things the law asks about. People call that negative assurance.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
A worked example
Take a community centre charity with £60,000 coming in for the year to 31 March 2026, up from £38,000 the year before. It's over £25,000, so it needs an examination, and it's well under £250,000, so any independent person with the right ability and experience can do it. As a non-company charity it can give its examiner simple receipts and payments accounts.
The examiner ticks the bank statements through to the cash book, checks the accounts add up to what the records show, and then spots the £22,000 jump. That's the analytical review at work. The trustees explain it's a one-off grant for a new kitchen, and the examiner asks to see the grant letter. Money given for one purpose is restricted to it, and they'll check the accounts treat it that way. If it's all there, the report says nothing has come to their attention, and the trustees file it with the accounts.
What you get at the end
A short report, usually a page or two, addressed to your trustees. It says whether anything has come to light suggesting your records weren't properly kept, the accounts don't agree with them, or the accounts don't meet the legal rules on form and content. If a reader needs to know something to understand the accounts, it says that too. Our post on what goes in the independent examiner's report takes it section by section, with an example.
And if the examiner comes across something serious, it doesn't stop with your trustees. Section 156 of the Act makes them report matters of material significance straight to the Charity Commission, such as signs of fraud involving a significant loss of the charity's money.
Who can be your examiner
While your gross income is £250,000 or less, any independent person with the right ability and practical experience can do it; for years ending on or after 30 September 2026 that limit is £500,000. Above it, the examiner must belong to one of the bodies listed in section 145 of the Act, or be a Fellow of the Association of Charity Independent Examiners. "Independent" rules out your trustees, your staff and whoever keeps your books. Our post on who can carry out an independent examination has the full list and the close-connection rules.
We examine charity accounts at every income level. We can prepare your accounts and examine them too, but not if we also keep your books: if we do your bookkeeping, someone else has to examine the accounts. Here's what you'd send us and how an examination with us runs. And if you're over the audit lines, here's how our audits work instead.
Frequently asked questions
- What does an independent examiner check?
- Whether proper accounting records were kept, whether the accounts agree with them, and whether the accounts are in the form the law requires, receipts and payments or accruals. Along the way they compare this year with last year, ask the trustees about anything unusual, check the trustees' annual report tells the same story as the accounts and, with accruals accounts, look at the policies, estimates and related party disclosures behind the figures.
- What happens if the examiner finds a problem?
- It depends how serious it is. If the examiner can't give the clean statements the regulations ask for, say because proper records weren't kept, the concern goes into the report, which makes it a qualified report, and the examiner has to tell the Charity Commission about it. Some matters always go to the Commission as well, such as signs of fraud involving a significant loss of the charity's money, or funds misapplied in breach of its trusts. Smaller points can be raised with the trustees without qualifying the report.
Need help with your charity's accounts?
Tell us about your charity, CIC or social enterprise and we will arrange a short introductory call.