CICs and Social Enterprises
The CIC Regulator (ORCIC) Explained: Who Regulates Community Interest Companies
The Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies is an independent office based at Companies House in Cardiff. It approves CIC formation, applies the community-interest test and enforces the asset lock. It isn't the Charity Commission.
The Charity Commission has nothing to do with CICs. The CIC regulator is the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies (ORCIC), an independent office based at Companies House in Cardiff. It decides who can become a CIC, applies the community-interest test to make sure CICs really do serve their community, and enforces the statutory asset lock. And a CIC isn't a charity.
Where the Regulator sits and what it is
The Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies is an independent regulatory office. It was created specifically to oversee CICs when the CIC structure was introduced by the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004. Although it is based at Companies House, it operates independently of Companies House's main functions.
This location matters because it reflects the fundamental nature of a CIC: a CIC is a company, not a charity. It registers at Companies House, files accounts and confirmation statements at Companies House, and is overseen by a regulator that sits within the Companies House framework. The Charity Commission has no role in the oversight of CICs.
The Regulator is sometimes referred to as ORCIC (from "Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies"). Both names refer to the same body.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. A specialist will come back to you, with no obligation.
What the Regulator actually does
It does four main jobs.
- Approves or refuses CIC formation. When a new CIC applies to register, the Regulator applies the community-interest test. If the Regulator isn't satisfied that a reasonable person might consider the proposed activities to be for the benefit of the community, the application is refused. This gate does not exist for ordinary companies.
- Reviews community interest reports. Every CIC files a CIC34 community interest company report alongside its annual accounts at Companies House, which forwards a copy of each one to the Regulator. The Regulator reviews these reports to satisfy itself that CICs continue to pursue their community interest objects. A CIC that files a vague or inadequate report can expect a query from the Regulator.
- Enforces the asset lock and dividend cap. CICs have a statutory asset lock that restricts how assets can be used or transferred. For CICs limited by shares there is also a statutory dividend cap limiting how much profit can be distributed to shareholders. The Regulator monitors compliance with both and can act where they are breached.
- Investigates and takes action. Where complaints are received about a CIC, or where the Regulator identifies concerns, it has statutory powers to investigate and take action. These powers are set out in the CIC legislation and guidance; the Regulator publishes annual reports on its activities.
The Regulator describes itself as light-touch: CICs are meant to be a flexible, accessible structure for social enterprises, and it steps in only as far as a concern needs. Day to day, most CICs only come across it through the annual CIC34 review. It'll answer general questions about CICs and the forms, but it won't advise on your particular case.
The community-interest test
The community-interest test is the central mechanism the Regulator uses both at formation and on an ongoing basis. The test asks whether a reasonable person might consider that the CIC's activities are carried on for the benefit of the community, or a section of it (section 35 of the 2004 Act).
This test is intentionally broad. It is not confined to deprived communities or traditional charitable causes. A CIC can pursue a very wide range of purposes, from arts and culture to environmental projects to social care, as long as the benefit is genuinely directed outward, toward the community, rather than to the members or shareholders of the CIC itself. A group that's defined only as your members, your staff or your friends won't count as a section of the community, and political parties and campaigning organisations can't be CICs at all.
The "reasonable person" framing is important. The test is objective, not subjective. The Regulator does not simply take the CIC's word for it that its activities are community-beneficial; it must be satisfied that an outside observer, applying a reasonable standard, could reach the same conclusion.
At formation, the community-interest test is assessed when the CIC submits its application along with its memorandum and articles of association describing its objects. On an ongoing basis, the test is applied through the community interest report in the CIC34, where the CIC must demonstrate that it has actually carried out community-beneficial activities during the year, not merely that it is constituted to do so.
The test itself is in the Act. The Regulator explains how it applies it in the CIC guidance pack, which also covers the asset lock, dividend caps and formation.
The CIC Regulator versus the Charity Commission
The most common source of confusion for people forming or researching a CIC is the relationship between the CIC Regulator and the Charity Commission. They are entirely separate bodies regulating entirely separate legal structures.
| Feature | CIC Regulator (ORCIC) | Charity Commission |
|---|---|---|
| Regulates | Community interest companies (CICs) | Registered charities in England and Wales |
| Sits at | Companies House | Independent government department |
| Key test | Community-interest test: might a reasonable person consider the activities to be for the benefit of the community? | Charitable purpose test: does the organisation exist for charitable purposes under the Charities Act 2011? |
| Registration route | CIC registers at Companies House; Regulator approves formation | Charity registers with the Charity Commission (CIO: Commission only; charitable company: Commission and Companies House) |
| Tax reliefs | None specific to CICs; pays corporation tax normally; no Gift Aid on income; no charitable rate relief | Gift Aid, charity rate relief (up to 80% mandatory plus discretionary top-up), exemption from most income and capital gains tax |
| Annual filing touchpoint | CIC34 community interest report (reviewed by Regulator); accounts at Companies House | Annual return to the Charity Commission; accounts filed with Commission above income thresholds |
The key practical consequence is that a CIC receives none of the tax reliefs that charities benefit from. As set out in the Regulator's own guidance, CICs are not charities and cannot claim Gift Aid on donations, cannot access charitable business rate relief, and pay corporation tax in the ordinary way. If your organisation's funding model depends on Gift Aid income or rate relief, a CIC is the wrong structure. The CIC versus charity comparison explores these trade-offs in detail.
When and how the Regulator can intervene
The CIC Regulator has statutory powers to investigate CICs and take action where it finds cause for concern. These powers arise from the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004 and the regulations made under it.
Investigations can be triggered by:
- Complaints from third parties. Any person can make a complaint to the Regulator about a CIC. Common grounds include concerns that the CIC is not genuinely pursuing its stated community interest objects, or that its assets are being misused.
- The annual CIC34 review. Where a community interest report raises concerns, or is inadequate, the Regulator may make further enquiries.
- Proactive monitoring. The Regulator monitors the CIC register and can identify concerns without waiting for a complaint.
Where the Regulator investigates, it has statutory powers to take action. The specific powers available are set out in the CIC legislation and the CIC guidance pack; the Regulator publishes annual reports summarising the types of cases it handles. In general terms, the Regulator can take proportionate steps to remedy the concern, up to and including more serious interventions where necessary.
The existence of these powers does not mean the Regulator operates as a heavy-handed enforcer. The CIC structure was designed to be accessible to social entrepreneurs, and the Regulator's published approach reflects that. Most CICs that file compliant CIC34s and operate within their stated objects will have no contact with the Regulator beyond the annual filing review.
Formation and ongoing filing touchpoints
For a CIC director, the Regulator's involvement is felt at two specific points: formation and the annual CIC34 cycle.
- Formation. When a CIC is incorporated, the application includes a form CIC36 (the community interest statement) and the articles of association. Companies House passes the documents to the Regulator and holds them until it decides. The Regulator reviews them to apply the community-interest test. If satisfied, the CIC is registered. If not, the Regulator can refuse registration or ask for amendments to the constitutional documents before approval is given. The step-by-step guide to setting up a CIC covers the forms and the fee.
- Annual CIC34 filing. Every year, alongside the annual accounts, the CIC files a CIC34 community interest company report at Companies House. This report covers the CIC's activities during the year, stakeholder consultation, asset lock compliance, and (for CICs limited by shares) dividend information. The Regulator reviews these reports. It costs £15 to file (Companies House's CIC step-by-step guidance). The CIC34 filing guide covers every section of the form in detail, including common rejection reasons.
- Changes to constitution. Where a CIC wants to change its objects or other key constitutional provisions, the Regulator's approval may be required. Changes that affect the community interest purpose are not simply a matter of passing a directors' or members' resolution; the Regulator must be satisfied the CIC continues to meet the community-interest test after the change. To change its objects, for example, a CIC passes a special resolution and sends form CIC14, signed by every director, with a fresh community interest statement.
For a fuller picture of the CIC structure, the CIC complete guide covers formation, governance, tax and filing obligations from start to finish. If you are deciding between a CIC and a charity, the CIC versus charity comparison is the right starting point. And if you want support with CIC accounts and compliance, the CIC accounting service page explains how we work with CIC directors.
Frequently asked questions
- Who regulates a community interest company?
- CICs are regulated by the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies (ORCIC), an independent office based at Companies House. The Charity Commission plays no role in regulating CICs.
- Is the CIC Regulator part of the Charity Commission?
- No. The CIC Regulator is an entirely separate body from the Charity Commission. It was created specifically to oversee CICs and is based at Companies House. The Charity Commission regulates charities; it has no jurisdiction over CICs.
- What is the community interest test?
- It's the test the Regulator applies when a CIC is formed and for as long as it exists. A company passes if a reasonable person might consider that its activities are carried on for the benefit of the community, or a real section of it. The test is in section 35 of the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004, and the CIC guidance pack on gov.uk explains how the Regulator applies it.
- Can the CIC Regulator remove a director?
- Yes. Section 46 of the Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004 lets the Regulator remove a director by order, and section 45 lets it appoint one; a director removed this way cannot be reappointed by the company. These powers can only be used where the conditions in section 41 are met: misconduct or mismanagement, a need to protect the company's property, or the CIC failing the community interest test or not pursuing its community interest objects. The Act also tells the Regulator to use its powers only as far as needed to keep confidence in CICs, so removing a director is not a routine step. Directors facing regulatory action should read the Regulator's published guidance or take professional advice.
- What happens if a CIC breaches its asset lock?
- The statutory asset lock is a core feature of the CIC structure. A breach is a serious matter: the Regulator can investigate and has powers to take action. Each year's CIC34 community interest report lists any assets the CIC passed on for less than full value, so the Regulator sees how the asset lock is working.
- Is a CIC a charity?
- No. A CIC is not a charity. It cannot claim Gift Aid on income, access charitable business rate relief, or benefit from other charity tax reliefs. It pays corporation tax in the normal way and is regulated by the CIC Regulator, not the Charity Commission. The CIC versus charity comparison on this site sets out the structural and tax differences in full.
- Where is the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies based?
- At Companies House in Cardiff (2nd Floor, Companies House, Crown Way, Cardiff, CF14 3UZ). It's an independent office, not part of Companies House's main operations, but it sits within the Companies House structure. You can email it at cicregulator@companieshouse.gov.uk.
- How do I complain about a CIC?
- Complain to the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies, by email to cicregulator@companieshouse.gov.uk or by post to its office at Companies House in Cardiff. The Regulator can investigate complaints and has statutory powers to take action where a CIC has failed to meet its obligations.
Need help with your charity's accounts?
Tell us about your charity, CIC or social enterprise and we will arrange a short introductory call.